As an SEO who has endured tours of duty in the three main job fields of SEO, I thought it may help to identify the benefits and hurdles of each area. Overall, each specific aspect of SEO relies upon one another in a variety of facets. Most importantly, knowledge sharing is consistent whether you work on a single website or a large amount of clients. SEO tactics change day to day, as do online marketing initiatives, and the SEO community as a whole adapts to these changes together.
SEO consulting offers the best and worst of both worlds; it just depends on what your personality type is and how you manage your resources. The perks of picking which clients you want to work with, the commanding hourly rate and nonexistent office hours are by far the biggest draw. When sales, billing, taxes and client management start to pile up you may start to second guess the daily gig. For me, it was when I could optimize a site and organic marketing campaign faster than I could sell or invoice for services rendered. It also took a toll on learning curves and the ability to reach out to others quickly when encountering an issue. The biggest downfall was having the authority to ensure implementations were done successfully and the desired results were achieved.
Client side SEO allowed the freedom to become an expert in niche markets. Since, typically, the work would be focused in one area, the freedom was there to explore every available opportunity to increase organic rankings or achieve the KPI’s for a specific website. The main hurdle with client side SEO work was how organic search fit into a company’s organizational structure. Was it marketing, development, or sales? Who was responsible for implementing changes? Who were the champions behind organic search? Who benefited? Often these questions were never answered, and windows of opportunity were missed.
All of this leads to agency SEO, a great mix of all the benefits and disadvantages of consulting and client side SEO. First off, I jumped ship for the client roster. Without a doubt, the lure of working with big brands was my main motivational goal for considering leaving the home office, traveling consistently, and joining what was the largest independent interactive agency in the world. The second reason was knowledge sharing. The ability to consult with web analytics specialists, user experience experts, and paid search teams can enhance an organic SEO campaign immensely. These offering, along with an in-house team of 40 SEOs, feed and technology experts provide all the necessary resources for a multitude of clients. As with any other SEO job, implementation is still the biggest hurdle and will continue to face the restrictions of legal reviews, coding guidelines and technology protocol.
Article by Sean Stahlman